Last Comic Standing
So, I really do like Last Comic Standing. Usually there are a number of non-ringers (i.e. people who HAVEN’T had a special on Comedy Central) who are just dead-on funny. Further, unlike American Idol and the like, every contestant has had to work really hard, and put themselves on the line again and again before even getting to the point where they can audition. The fact is that lots of people just end up with a great voice. But no matter how funny you are, you have to generate material (which is different than shooting the shit with your friends and making them laugh). More, singers don’t get heckled, as a rule. In short, the folks on Last Comic have earned it, and the people on American Idol just haven’t had to go through the wringer that way.
This year, my number 1 choice is God’s Pottery.
Unfortunately, there are always a few who have no business being there. I do understand that the show is about making money, selling ad time, and so forth. Therefor, the people picked have to fit into that framework. I understand, and, as I said at the beginning, they’ve all had to work to get where they are in the first place. But sometimes I have a real problem with one of them. At the moment, its Papa CJ. First, he just isn’t that funny. Thats a taste issue, yes, so I can let that slide. The thing it that he falls into one of my “Annoying Comedian Classes”. This includes comics with just one gag, comics with just one source of humor (Josh Blue, anyone? BTW, I think he’s pretty funny and will do well if he can learn to write about things other than his handicap), and so forth. Papa CJ drops into the most annoying bucket of all. He thinks he’s edgy. He comes out and says he’s edgy and offensive (all without irony):
Papa CJ’s cutting edge wit & social commentary represents the rising voice of a billion people - fresh and entertaining with a sly sting in the tail.
And, perhaps in India, he is. I don’t know. But he isn’t in the U.S., and that gets in the way of him actually being funny. He has a bit where he picks an audiance member and talks about being reincarnated as the guys kid and getting to suck on his girlfriend’s breasts. This is a funny line, but he goes into it by saying ‘Oh, yes, now you are all probably mad at me for saying these things and are thinking I’ll die’. But he hasn’t said anything controversial (at least in a comedy club). Its sort of like bragging about having paid your taxes on time and then talking about how people are so offended by you for being so smart.
Anyhow…
Sphere: Related Content